Private Clonal / Tissue-Culture Stock
Clonal, grafted or tissue-culture mahogany sold by private nurseries. We found no yield trial for any such stock in India, and no clone proven resistant to the shoot borer. The costs are higher, so ask for trial data in writing before you pay.
Quick facts
- Crop
- Mahogany
- Type
- Seedling (private nursery / clonal)
- Season
- Kharif
- Rotation age
- 30–35 year rotation for seed-raised trees (ICRAF); no clonal rotation found
- Seed rate
- Planted as seedlings. At 3 x 3 m you need about 1,111 plants a hectare (about 450 an acre); at 2.5 x 2.5 m, 1,600 a hectare (about 648 an acre); at 10 x 3 m, 333 a hectare (about 135 an acre).
- Expected yield
- No published yield trial for a mahogany clone sold in India was found
- Suitable soil
- Deep, well-drained loam to red laterite
- Disease resistance
- No clone is proven resistant to the shoot borer
- Release
- Private nursery clonal selection (various nurseries) · no formal release · no trial data found
Actual yield depends on sowing time, soil, irrigation, weather, seed quality and crop management.
About this variety
Some private nurseries sell mahogany (Swietenia macrophylla) plants raised from cuttings, grafts or tissue culture rather than seed. The idea is sound: a clone repeats its mother tree, so if the mother had a straight stem, the plants should too, while seed-raised mahogany varies. But the evidence is thin. We found no published yield trial of a mahogany clone sold in India, and no clone shown to resist the shoot borer. The best-documented work on resistance is a Costa Rican grafting study (Perez and others, 2010) with the related borer Hypsipyla grandella. It is useful for what it shows about grafting, not as a promise for Indian clones. Prices are set by each nursery and we found no published rate.
Should you pick this variety?
Choose private clonal or tissue-culture mahogany only if the nursery can show, in writing, which mother tree each clone came from, where and for how many years the clone was tested, and how many trees were in the test. Grafting is a real tool: a Costa Rican study found that resistant rootstocks protected susceptible cedar scions. But it did not make mahogany immune, and mahogany on one of the rootstocks looked incompatible. If the nursery cannot answer, a government or KFRI seedling at a lower price is the safer buy.
Sowing & cultivation
- Sowing timePlant out after the rains begin. Ask the nursery how old the plants are and how long they have been in the bag.
- Seed ratePlanted as seedlings. At 3 x 3 m you need about 1,111 plants a hectare (about 450 an acre); at 2.5 x 2.5 m, 1,600 a hectare (about 648 an acre); at 10 x 3 m, 333 a hectare (about 135 an acre).
- SpacingMahogany needs light. ICRAF says plantations use 10 x 3 m (333 stems a hectare) and thin to 150 to 250 stems. Clones do not change that.
Pest & disease considerations
Major pests
- Shoot borer (Hypsipyla robusta): treat every clone as susceptible unless the nursery shows field trial data.
- A Costa Rican study found that intact big-leaf mahogany plants lost 100% (first test) and 80% (second test) of apical buds to the related borer Hypsipyla grandella.
Advantages & considerations
Why farmers may choose it
- A clone repeats its mother tree, so plants are more even than seed-raised stock.
- If the mother tree had a straight stem, the clones can have the same form.
- Grafting is an active research tool against the borer.
Things to consider
- No yield trial and no borer-resistant clone were found. Ignore "borer-proof" claims without field data.
- In the Costa Rican study, big-leaf mahogany grafted onto Toona ciliata appeared incompatible.
- Where all the trees are one clone, a pest or disease that beats one beats all. That is our reading, not a trial finding.
Suitable regions
States this variety is recommended for — check locally, since a state can have more than one recommended zone.
- Kerala
- Karnataka
- Tamil Nadu
- Andhra Pradesh
- Maharashtra
Six questions to ask before paying more for a clone
The best-documented grafting work is a Costa Rican study of big-leaf mahogany and Spanish cedar (Perez and others, 2010). Plants were infested with the shoot borer Hypsipyla grandella. Intact mahogany lost 100% of its apical buds in the first test and 80% in the second. Cedar grafted onto the resistant rootstocks Khaya senegalensis and Toona ciliata lost far less. Grafting mahogany onto Toona ciliata looked incompatible. Autografting mahogany onto mahogany cut the frass piles by 51%. The authors asked for long-term field trials before anyone relies on it.
That is the honest state of the science. It supports asking questions, not trusting claims. Ask the nursery: (1) Which mother tree did each clone come from, and where does it stand? (2) How was the plant made: cuttings, graft or tissue culture? If grafted, onto which rootstock? (3) Where was the clone tested, for how many years, and with how many trees? (4) What was the shoot borer damage compared with seedlings in the same plot? (5) Can I visit a plot older than three years? (6) What do you do if the plants fail?
A nursery that answers all six, with papers, may be worth a higher price. One that says "borer-proof" and nothing more is selling a hope. We found no published rate for clonal mahogany in India, so the price you are quoted has nothing to compare with except government seedlings.
Can you keep your own planting material?
These plants are copies of a mother tree, raised by cuttings, grafts or tissue culture. Do not expect seed from them to give the same tree: seed from a clone gives mixed seedlings, as it does for any mahogany. If you want more clones, buy them from a nursery that can name the mother tree.
How it compares with other varieties
Every Mahogany variety with a page on this site, side by side. The row for this page is highlighted.
| Variety | Best for | Rotation age | Yield | States |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kerala Forest Department Seed Source | Easiest-to-find Kerala seedlings | 30–35 year rotation in plantation forestry (ICRAF) | No Indian volume table found; plantation wood weighs 485–840 kg per cubic metre (ICRAF) | Kerala |
| KFRI Improved Planting Stock | Research-backed nursery practice | 30–35 year rotation in plantation forestry (ICRAF) | No Indian volume table found; KFRI nursery trial: 92% germination when sown flat | Kerala |
| Private Clonal / Tissue-Culture Stockthis page | Only with trial proof in writing | 30–35 year rotation for seed-raised trees (ICRAF); no clonal rotation found | No published yield trial for a mahogany clone sold in India was found | Kerala, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, Maharashtra |
| Tamil Nadu Forest Department Seed Source | Tamil Nadu buyers: check the species | 30–35 year rotation in plantation forestry (ICRAF) | No Indian volume table found; no Tamil Nadu yield figure published | Tamil Nadu |
Tools for this crop
The numbers you need next: how much seed to buy, whether the lot germinates, what the fertilizer bill looks like and what Mahogany is selling for.
- Seed Rate CalculatorHow much seed your Mahogany plot needs, corrected for the germination of the lot you bought.
- Seed Variety FinderFilter every Mahogany variety on this site by state, season, duration and soil.
- Fertilizer CalculatorTurn the NPK recommendation for Mahogany into bags of urea, DAP and MOP for your field size.
- Crop CalendarMonth-by-month sowing, weeding, irrigation and harvest dates for Mahogany in your state.
- Crop Profit CalculatorPut your seed, labour and input costs against the yield you expect from this variety.
- Mandi Price CheckerToday's Mahogany rate in your nearest mandi, before you fix a price with a trader.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a shoot borer-resistant mahogany clone?
We found none shown in a published trial. A Costa Rican study found that resistance from African mahogany (Khaya senegalensis) and Toona ciliata rootstocks could be passed to some grafted scions, and that mahogany on Toona ciliata looked incompatible. Its authors asked for long-term field trials. An Indian review in 2003 said no reliable, affordable protection existed through a full rotation.
How is a clone different from a grafted plant?
A clone is any plant made from a piece of one tree, by cuttings, grafting or tissue culture. A grafted plant joins a shoot of one tree (the scion) onto the roots of another (the rootstock). The Costa Rican grafting study mattered because the rootstock changed how the scion was attacked. Ask a nursery which of these it sells and, if grafted, the rootstock species.
What does clonal mahogany cost?
We found no published price. Each nursery sets its own, and clonal plants cost more than seedlings. Ask for the rate per plant, the age of the plants, the mother tree and the replacement terms in writing. Compare with a government or KFRI seedling, whose rate the institute lists on its Nursery page.
Will clonal mahogany grow faster?
Only if the mother tree was a fast grower and the clone keeps that trait on your land. We found no published growth trial of a mahogany clone in India, so no growth figure can be quoted. A faster start is possible but unproven. The rotation in ICRAF is 30 to 35 years for plantation forestry.
Sourced from: Perez and others, Neotropical Entomology 39(4), 2010 — grafting mahogany and cedar on resistant rootstocks, shoot borer damage (Costa Rica), Misra, Khan and Bhandari, Indian Journal of Forestry, 2003 — Hypsipyla shoot borer: biology and integrated management, Swietenia macrophylla — Agroforestree Database (Orwa and others, 2009), World Agroforestry, Moor and others, Electronic J. Plant Breeding 12(4), 2021 — variability and plus tree selection in Swietenia macrophylla, Kerala, Nurseries — Kerala Forest Research Institute. editorial policy.
