PE-11
A PAU clone of the PE series that led pot trials in saline soil and under flooding. The evidence is from pots and young plants; no field rotation yield or release notice was found.
Quick facts
- Type
- Tissue-culture / clonal cutting
- Season
- All seasons
- Rotation age
- No field rotation data; the PAU pot trials ran 45 to 140 days
- Seed rate
- Rooted cuttings from a mist chamber, not seed. Ask PAU or the nursery how many plants of PE-11 are available before you plan an area.
- Expected yield
- No field yield published; best height, collar diameter and biomass in PAU pot trials
- Suitable soil
- Saline / marginal
- Disease resistance
- No gall-wasp or disease rating published
- Release
- Studied at PAU, Ludhiana (Department of Forestry and Natural Resources). No release notification found.
Actual yield depends on sowing time, soil, irrigation, weather, seed quality and crop management.
About this variety
PE-11 is a clone of the PE series studied by the Department of Forestry and Natural Resources at Punjab Agricultural University, Ludhiana. In a clonal trial at PAU the PE clones were raised in the university's mist chamber, while C-411 was bought from a nursery. In a pot study of 8 clones in normal, saline and mixed soil (Dhillon, Dhillon and Singh, Indian Forester, 2019), PE-11 had the highest mean plant height and collar diameter at 45, 110 and 140 days. It also had the highest leaf, branch, stem and root biomass in every soil. All clones lost biomass in saline soil, but PE-11 kept the highest share. In a second pot trial with 5 clones under 4 moisture levels, PE-11 had the highest root biomass.
Should you pick this variety?
Choose PE-11 if your Punjab land is saline or floods in the monsoon, and you are willing to plant on thinner evidence than C-413 has. In PAU's pot trial with 8 clones in normal, saline and mixed soil, PE-11 had the highest plant height and collar diameter at all three ages, the highest biomass in every soil, and kept the largest share of its biomass in saline soil. In a moisture trial it had the highest root biomass. All of that is pots and young plants. We found no field rotation yield and no release notice. Plant a test strip in your worst patch beside C-413 first, and ask PAU's forestry department what it advises now.
Sowing & cultivation
- Seed rateRooted cuttings from a mist chamber, not seed. Ask PAU or the nursery how many plants of PE-11 are available before you plan an area.
- SpacingNo spacing is published for PE-11. The Chief Conservator of Forests, Punjab, wrote in 1992 that boundary planting is commonly 1.75 to 2.25 m apart, and that blocks grown with field crops use 4 x 4 m or 6 x 2 m.
- IrrigationIn PAU's moisture trial the growth was highest at 25% soil moisture, and fully submerged roots cut growth for all 5 clones. The plants survived and formed adventitious roots.
Soil & climate
Soil
- Suitable soil
- Saline and seasonally waterlogged soil in the PAU pot trials; EC values are not given in the abstracts we could open
- Irrigation
- Submerged roots cut the growth of every clone tested, PE-11 included, though plants survived. Do not plant it where water stands all year.
Pest & disease considerations
Major diseases
- Gall wasp (Leptocybe invasa): no rating published for PE-11
- Termites on young plants
Advantages & considerations
Why farmers may choose it
- Highest height and collar diameter in PAU's saline pot trial at all three ages, and the most biomass in every soil type.
- Highest root biomass under moisture stress, and among the two clones, with PE-13, rated most promising for biomass.
- Reported 100% survival in a PAU effluent-irrigation trial.
Things to consider
- The evidence is from pots and young plants. No field rotation yield, no field-plantation record and no release notice was found.
- In saline soil every clone lost biomass. PE-11 lost the least, but it still grew less than in normal soil.
- Salinity (EC) levels for the trials are not given in the abstracts we could open, so you cannot match your own soil to the trial.
Suitable regions
Studied by the Department of Forestry and Natural Resources, PAU, Ludhiana, in pot trials for saline soil, flooding and moisture stress, and in an effluent-irrigation trial. We found no release notice and no field plantation record.
- Punjab
What a pot trial can tell you, and what it cannot
The PE-11 evidence is real, but it is a particular kind. PAU grew 8 clones in pots filled with normal, saline or mixed soil at Ludhiana and measured them at 45, 110 and 140 days. PE-11 led on height, collar diameter and biomass in every soil. A second pot trial held 5 clones at 4 moisture levels, from fully submerged to 15% moisture. A third trial irrigated clones with effluent and reported 100% survival for PE-11.
Pots show how a young plant reacts to one stress with everything else controlled. They do not show how a tree grows for 4 or 5 years in a field with roots going down, the water table moving, and salts rising and falling with the season. The field record we found for Punjab belongs to other clones. C-413, for example, has 2.5 to 4 year results at four sites.
So treat PE-11 as a promising clone for a hard patch, not a proven one. Order a small lot, say 50 plants. Plant them in your worst corner, with 50 of C-413 beside them. Count survivors after the first monsoon and again after the second. Measure the height of 10 trees from each row. After two seasons you will have your own field trial, and it will matter more than any pot result.
Can you keep your own planting material?
It is multiplied as rooted cuttings, so every tree is a copy of the mother plant. Seed collected from a clonal tree would give mixed plants. Ask for plants from a nursery that can show the PAU source of its PE-11 mother plants.
How it compares with other varieties
Every Eucalyptus (Safeda / Nilgiri) variety with a page on this site, side by side. The row for this page is highlighted.
| Variety | Best for | Rotation age | Yield | States |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| C-2045 | Normal drained land only | Punjab trials measured 4 years; final cutting age depends on your buyer's size and rate | 24 to 30 m³/ha/yr at 4 years in the Semi trial; last of 9 on a waterlogged site at Muktsar | Punjab, Haryana |
| C-413 | Punjab plains; strongest trial record | Punjab trials measured 2.5 to 4 years; final cutting age depends on your buyer's size and rate | 28.80 m³/ha/yr over bark at 3 years (Ludhiana); 36.07 at 2.5 years (Amritsar) | Punjab, Haryana |
| Eucalyptus camaldulensis (River Red Gum) | Flood-prone or dry sites; check the seed source | Growth is measured at 3 to 5 years in the trials we found; thinning at 5 years and sawn timber after 10 (ICRAF) | No per-hectare yield for seedling stock found; one Tamil Nadu spacing trial reached 113.59 t/ha of biomass at 3 x 1 m | Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, Punjab |
| Eucalyptus tereticornis (Mysore Gum) | Seed-grown safeda; low-cost start | Rotation varies with site and purpose: 5 to 7 years in Congo, 9 to 12 years with thinning in Argentina (ICRAF) | Seed-origin stock gave 6 to 10 m³/ha/yr in ITC's comparison; clones gave 12 to 44 | Punjab, Haryana, Uttar Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh |
| IFGTB EC Clones (EC-1 to EC-4) | Pulpwood in Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh | No rotation age or per-hectare figure for EC-1 to EC-4 found; IFGTB gives a pulpwood gain of 25 to 40% over the benchmark clone | IFGTB claims 25 to 40% more pulpwood than the clone in common use, depending on site and practice | Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh |
| ITC Bhadrachalam Clones | Farm-forestry buy-back; Andhra Pradesh | Trials measured 2 to 4 years; rotation depends on your buyer | 12 to 44 m³/ha/yr for the 72 selected clones, 20 to 44 for the best 11, against 6 to 10 for seed-route plantations (ITC, 1999) | Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Punjab |
| PE-11this page | Saline or flooded land (pot evidence) | No field rotation data; the PAU pot trials ran 45 to 140 days | No field yield published; best height, collar diameter and biomass in PAU pot trials | Punjab |
Tools for this crop
The numbers you need next: how much seed to buy, whether the lot germinates, what the fertilizer bill looks like and what Eucalyptus (Safeda / Nilgiri) is selling for.
- Seed Rate CalculatorHow much seed your Eucalyptus (Safeda / Nilgiri) plot needs, corrected for the germination of the lot you bought.
- Seed Variety FinderFilter every Eucalyptus (Safeda / Nilgiri) variety on this site by state, season, duration and soil.
- Fertilizer CalculatorTurn the NPK recommendation for Eucalyptus (Safeda / Nilgiri) into bags of urea, DAP and MOP for your field size.
- Crop CalendarMonth-by-month sowing, weeding, irrigation and harvest dates for Eucalyptus (Safeda / Nilgiri) in your state.
- Crop Profit CalculatorPut your seed, labour and input costs against the yield you expect from this variety.
- Mandi Price CheckerToday's Eucalyptus (Safeda / Nilgiri) rate in your nearest mandi, before you fix a price with a trader.
Frequently asked questions
Is PE-11 an official PAU release?
We found no release notification. PAU's forestry department studies the PE series of clones, which it raised in its own mist chamber, in pot and effluent trials. Earlier descriptions that called PE-11 a PAU release for south-western Punjab are not supported by the papers we could open. Ask PAU for its current recommendation.
How much salt can PE-11 take?
The abstracts we could open do not give the salinity (EC) of the trial soils, so we cannot tell you a number. They say all clones grew less in saline soil than in normal soil, and PE-11 grew best of the 8. Ask PAU for the EC values, then test your own soil with a soil-testing lab.
Can PE-11 stand flooding?
Partly. In PAU's moisture trial, fully submerged roots cut growth for all 5 clones, but the plants survived and formed adventitious roots. PE-11 had the highest root biomass in the trial and, with PE-13, the best collar diameter. That is a pot result, so seasonal flooding may be workable, but standing water all year is not tested.
Should I plant PE-11 or C-413?
On normal or seasonally flooded land with drainage, C-413 has years of field results in Punjab. On saline land, PE-11 led PAU's pot trial and C-413 was not in it. Choose by your soil. If you are unsure, plant both in side-by-side rows and keep a count of survivors.
Sourced from: Growth Performance of Eucalyptus Clones in Saline Soils — Indian Forester 145(4), 2019 (Dhillon, Dhillon, Singh, PAU), Growth performance of Eucalyptus clones under varying moisture levels — Indian Journal of Agroforestry, A review of clonal and plantation trials of Eucalyptus in India — Biological Forum 13(2), 2021, Survival and growth performance of Eucalyptus clones irrigated with effluents from liquor factory — ResearchGate, Greening of earth: Eucalyptus as a raw material for forest based industries — S.K. Kapur, Chief Conservator of Forests, Punjab; IPPTA 4(1), March 1992. editorial policy.
